Gaslighting vs. Insensitivity: Know the Difference

Photo by Vera Arsic on Pexels.com

The term gaslighting has become widely used in recent years, and with that has come some understandable confusion. While it’s an important concept to name, it’s also one that is often misused.

What Gaslighting Really Means

Gaslighting refers to a specific form of emotional and psychological abuse. It occurs when someone intentionally and repeatedly undermines another person’s sense of reality. This is done through ongoing behaviours that dismiss, deny, or distort experiences that the abuser knows to be true, with the aim of making the other person doubt their own perceptions, memory, or sanity.

The term comes from a play that was later adapted into the film Gaslight. In the story, a husband deliberately creates situations that cause his wife to question her mental stability. He dims the gas lights in their home, hides objects, and then denies these actions when she notices them. Over time, this erosion of her trust in herself allows him to manipulate and exploit her.

How It Shows Up in Relationships:

In modern usage, gaslighting describes a similar pattern of manipulation. It can occur in intimate relationships, families, workplaces, or other settings where there is an imbalance of power. What makes gaslighting distinct is that it is not accidental or careless. Gaslighting is an orchestrated pattern of behaviour, carried out with the clear intention of making someone doubt their reality when the abuser knows that person’s reality to be true.

Gaslighting vs Insensitivity 

It’s also important to clarify what gaslighting isn’t.

Many people use the term to describe experiences of feeling misunderstood, dismissed, or disagreed with. This might include situations where someone is being insensitive, overly opinionated, or pushing their own perspective in a way that feels invalidating or undermining. These experiences can be painful and should absolutely be addressed, but they are not necessarily gaslighting.

If a person genuinely believes their own perspective to be true, even if they are wrong or expressing it poorly, this does not meet the definition of gaslighting. Miscommunication, conflict, defensiveness, or lack of emotional awareness can all cause harm, but they are different from intentional reality manipulation. Using the term gaslighting in these situations can muddy the waters and, in itself, become problematic as it is a serious accusation. 

Gaslighting occurs when someone knows your perspective is accurate and deliberately attempts to replace it with a false version of reality in order to gain control or power over you.

How Therapy Can Help

Counselling/Therapy can provide you with a space to reflect on your relationship in order to assess if the behaviour is problematic behaviour rather than specifically manipulation in the form of gaslighting. 

If it’s the former then this is something you can get help addressing, either through individual or couples therapy. 

If you feel that the behaviour is in fact gaslighting, and is part of a pattern of manipulative behaviour, that your experience is being discredited by a partner who is seeking power over you: then I suggest that couples therapy might not be helpful.

Gaslighting is a type of coersive control. Your partner is likely to use couples therapy as a way to further their own narrative, or to punish you later for what you discolse in session. In this case you are safer to seek individual support.

If you believe you are being gaslit, please know that this behaviour is abusive and deeply harmful. You deserve support and to feel grounded in your own reality. Reaching out to a therapist or support organisations such as Women’s Aid, Men’s Aid, or Safe Ireland can be an important step toward safety, clarity, and healing.

You are not imagining it — and you don’t have to face it alone. We’re here to help.

If you would like to read more about control and self-esteem in relationships check out this post here.

First published at WellnessRooms.ie

The 4 Defence Styles in Relationships

Photo by Marcelo Chagas on Pexels.com

Most of us would like to think we handle relationship bumps reasonably well. But the truth is, when we feel hurt by the person we love, something in us often reacts long before we’ve had a chance to think. We go into old, familiar patterns — patterns designed to protect us, even if they often make things worse.

In therapy, I often see people who wonder why a small comment from their partner can spark such a big internal reaction. Understanding your defensive style can be a really useful starting point.


The Many Ways We Protect Ourselves

When something feels emotionally risky, we tend to lean on one or more of the following responses:

  • Fight – pushing back, getting argumentative or trying to take control.
  • Flight – stepping away emotionally or physically; avoiding the difficult conversation.
  • Freeze – becoming stuck, overwhelmed, unable to respond.
  • Fawn – appeasing, smoothing things over, trying to keep the peace at any cost.
  • Fix – getting busy ‘sorting the problem’ instead of facing the feelings beneath it.
  • Collapse/Submit – sinking into hopelessness or despair.

If you recognise yourself in more than one of these, you’re in good company. Most people move between them depending on the situation.


Terry Real’s Relationship Grid

Terry Real, founder of Relational Life Therapy, designed a simple but powerful grid that helps us understand why we react the way we do.

The grid has two axes:

1. Pride ↔ Shame (How we feel about ourselves)

On one end we have pridefulness — that “I’m right” stance. On the other, shame, that sinking feeling of being “less than.”
Many people are surprised to learn that pride and shame are two sides of the same coin. Pride often masks deeper feelings of inadequacy; shame shrinks us down.

The middle ground — humility — is where we feel equally worthy as our partner.

2. Over-Boundaried ↔ Under-Boundaried (How we relate)

Some of us ‘pull away’ when hurt. We go inward, detach, or guard ourselves — this is the over-boundaried or ‘walled off’ side.
Others ‘lean in too much’, becoming over-involved in our partner’s feelings — this is under-boundaried.

The healthy centre is connection with differentiation: close, but not merged; separate, but not distant.


The Four Defensive Positions

OVER-BOUNDARIED & PRIDEFUL
(Grandiose, distant)

• Emotional Flight
• Righteous
• Mean-spirited
• Under-involved
• Doesn’t express vulnerability
UNDER-BOUNDARIED & PRIDEFUL
(Grandiose, enmeshed)|

• Fight / Fix
• Righteous
• Over-concerned
• Over-engaged
• Overt-control
OVER-BOUNDARIED & SHAMEFUL
(Shameful, withdrawn)

• Freeze / Collapse
• Hopelessness
• Emotional retreat / avoidance
• Feels defeated, downtodden
• Shut down
UNDER-BOUNDARIED & SHAMEFUL
(Shameful, enmeshed)
• Fawn
• Over-accommodating
• Self-neglect
• Fear of upsetting partner
• Subtle control

Where these two axes meet, we get four common ways people behave when they’re at their worst:

1. Prideful and Withdrawn

“I’m right — and I don’t need this”
Here you might shut down, retreat, or avoid the conversation altogether.
This is the classic flight reaction — disconnecting to avoid discomfort.

2. Prideful and Enmeshed

“I’m right — and you need to see it my way.”
Here you stay engaged, but in a controlling or argumentative way.
This can look like fight or fix — lots of energy, but not much listening.

3. Shameful and Withdrawn

“I give up.”
This is where people feel small, hopeless or overwhelmed.
Often a freeze or collapse response.
It can look like disengagement, but it’s really despair in disguise.

4. Shameful and Enmeshed

“Your needs come first — mine don’t matter.”
Here you may over-accommodate your partner, defer, or try to placate them.
This is the fawn response — and it can become passively resentful over time. It may involve subtle attempts to influence your partner’s behaviour.


Why These Reactions Make Things Harder

Each of these defensive positions gets in the way of clearing the air.

  • If you’re on the withdrawn side (positions 1 and 3), you avoid the very engagement needed to repair.
  • If you’re on the enmeshed side (positions 2 and 4), you may push too hard or try too much to get your partner to change.

Both are understandable. Both are human. And both can keep us stuck.


The Real Challenge: Moving Towards the Centre

The centre of the grid is the ideal:
connected, humble, grounded, and able to tolerate difference.

This doesn’t mean we agree with our partner all the time — or that we never get triggered. It simply means we’re able to stay connected to ourselves and to them, even when we disagree.

Some things that help:

  • Staying curious rather than righteous
  • Remembering that differences don’t mean danger
  • Allowing space for your partner’s feelings
  • Staying with your own experience without pulling away
  • Letting go of the idea that only one of you can be “right”

Relationships naturally bring up old wounds — that’s not a sign something is wrong. In fact, it’s part of why intimate relationships can be such powerful places for growth.


Empathy and Understanding

When we can step back from our defensive positions, empathy follows naturally. We begin to see the hurt underneath our partner’s reaction, and we understand our own responses more clearly as well.

With that understanding, communication becomes easier, conflict becomes less threatening, and staying connected — even during difficult moments — becomes more possible.

You can also find this article at www.wellnessrooms.ie

If you’d like to get a sense of your primary defence style, Terry Real’s quiz below is a helpful place to start. Just remember: the result reflects the version of you under stress, not the whole of who you are. The quadrant descriptions are quite general, so they can sound more extreme than what you might recognise in yourself. After you get your quiz results, feel free to unsubscribe from Terry Real’s emails if you don’t want to stay on his mailing list.

Empathy in Couples Therapy

Photo by Min An on Pexels.com

In my experience empathy can make or break a relationship. Empathy can be improved through couples therapy.

Communication

When a couple attends for therapy they have usually come to a stalemate in one or more aspects of their communication. The individuals might feel taken for granted. Both parties tend to be extreemely hurt or have reached a state of apathy in the relationship. Often they are at various stages of believing that they are in the right and that the relationship would be okay, if only their partner changed. But self-reflection of both parties is required for couples therapy to move forward.

Hurt and Defence

When we feel hurt, we feel vulnerable. Vulnerability activates the primal defence system. Many understand this as the fight/flight/freeze response. When we feel annoyed or hurt, our focus turns to protecting ourselves. It’s very difficult to feel empathy for the person who we see as responsible for our hurt. Simply put, hurt creates defence, and this effects how we communicate with, and regard our partner. When we are feeling sensitive about, or triggered by, a particular issue, our partner’s words or actions can land on a ‘sore spot’.

Blame

Hurt can create blame, and blame breeds resentment and self righteousness. It sends us into a place of rumination about our partners’s wrongdoings. Seeing them as the ‘bad guy’ and ourselves as the victim. This limits our perspective and our ability to self-reflect.

Creating a space within ourselves to put ourselves in the our partner’s shoes is so important. Even when we believe they are objectively in the wrong. Empathy can open up the ability to communicate, particularly about the problematic issue. It makes it easier to listen to our partner’s experience.

Self-reflection

Self-reflection also opens up the opportunity to see if there are themes in the relationship that trigger your hurt. Own your own emotions. Using the format of ‘I feel…(emotion e.g. hurt).. when you….. (insert the behaviour here). This sentence format helps to remove the aspect of blame from the interaction.

No one person is going to get it right 100% of the time. It’s important to own where we might have been hurtful or unsupportive in the relationship, including when this was unintentional, or a result of a misunderstanding. Owning what we are responsible for usually makes it easier for our partner to also own what has been their responsibility. Of course this works best if both parties attempt to feel empathy for the other.

*The above does not necessarily apply in cases within abusive relationships, including coercive control. Please seek individual professional help if you are living with domestic violence e.g. https://www.safeireland.iehttps://www.safeireland.ie , https://www.womensaid.ie https://www.mensaid.iehttps://www.mensaid.ie

You can also find this article at www.wellnessrooms.ie

The 4 Elements of Healthy Relationships

Conflict Styles